The Jewishness of Passover Refutes Transubstantiation

After this interview I was thinking about the possibility of other examples where Jesus uses a present physical object in a purely symbolic sense and I think we do have some. When Jesus spoke to the woman at the well He told her that she should ask Him for water, and while there was physical water present the real point Jesus is making is that she needs non-physical water which is representative of new life in the Holy Spirit. Jesus also manifested bread for the crowd but told them that this was food that perishes and they need food that gives everlasting life. He goes on to show that this food is belief in Jesus. Even in the favorite passage for those who promote transubstantiation (John 6) Jesus adds the clarity/commentary that the flesh profits nothing and the Spirit gives life. This is not merely saying the word “spirit” means “symbolism”; rather it is saying that “spirit” is not “flesh” and cannot be interpreted to mean “my physical body being eaten by you”. A whole lot more can and should be said about all this but I hope that the above answer will be seen as offering strong support simply for the fact that the Jewish context of the Last Supper is such that we should conclude symbolic meaning in the act and not transubstantiation.

This is just one question from a long interview I did for the moderators of the r/Bible subreddit. They asked their subreddit to send me a bunch of questions and I spent a lot of time preparing so that I would be able to offer the best answers I could. I’ll be posting these answers as individual videos so keep an eye out for the rest in the set.

I’m Mike Winger and my goal is to help you learn to think biblically about everything!

I go live almost every Monday and Friday at 1pm. Monday is usually a vs by vs teaching and Friday is a live Q&A where I take questions from the live chat on YT.

My website


(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

About The Author

Mike Winger Thoughtful videos aimed at carefully understanding and defending a truly biblical worldview. I desire to preach Christ to those who don't know Him and encourage and exhort those that do. I WELCOME comments and advice on how I can learn to do this better. Thank you!!! You can help by watching, liking, subscribing and sharing the videos you want others to see.

Related Content


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *